Police Scotland says 11 officers convicted of criminal offences remain employed by the force. Eight of those convictions involved violence against women and girls. Some officers have remained on the payroll for more than a year after conviction. This is not an administrative embarrassment or an unfortunate delay in processing paperwork. It is a profound failure by an institution entrusted with protecting the public, including women and girls.
The Chief Constable, Jo Farrell, has described the situation as “intolerable”. But the question is not whether it is intolerable. It is why it has been allowed to happen, who is responsible, and what it tells us about the way Police Scotland responds to violence against women and girls.
Farrell has blamed shortcomings in the existing misconduct regulations. Calum Steele, former general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, argues that this shifts responsibility away from the force’s own Professional Standards Department (PSD), which is ultimately her responsibility. He claims that officers convicted of criminal offences could be dismissed within five weeks under existing arrangements. Police Scotland disputes this, saying the 35-working-day period applies to only one stage of the process and that criminal matters, including appeals, must be concluded before misconduct proceedings can progress.
That cannot become an excuse for a system in which officers convicted of violence against women and girls can remain employed for months, or more than a year, while the public is told that the rules are to blame. The force must be able to explain what action it takes to protect the public during that period, and why the process is so slow. Calling the situation intolerable does not discharge the responsibility to put it right.
Nor is this simply a question of how quickly an individual officer can be dismissed. The wider problem is whether the police can be trusted to investigate and discipline their own. The reforms now being considered by Holyrood would introduce independent, legally qualified chairs for misconduct hearings involving senior officers, while retaining police-led proceedings for junior ranks. In other words, the system would offer different levels of independence depending on an officer’s rank.
That is particularly difficult to defend when the allegations concern an institution’s handling of violence against women and girls. Dame Elish Angiolini’s 2020 review recommended that gross misconduct hearings involving officers of all ranks should be chaired by independent, legally qualified people. The recommendation recognises a basic problem: an organisation cannot convincingly hold itself to account if it retains control over the process by which its own misconduct is judged.
The force’s record on appeals adds to the concern. Police Scotland says 94 per cent of 132 gross misconduct outcomes since 2024 have not been amended by a Police Appeals Tribunal. It also confirmed that eight cases resulted in dismissal being replaced by a lesser sanction, despite findings of gross misconduct being upheld. Farrell told MSPs that tribunals reached different determinations in nine cases. Steele says the last nine dismissal decisions appealed were overturned. These descriptions are not identical. But they make the case for transparency stronger: the public should understand how serious misconduct is investigated, how sanctions are decided and why dismissals are changed.
There are further questions about whether senior officers are subject to the same standards as the rest of the force. Steele points to complaints against chief officers, including allegations of discrimination, abuse of position, bullying and harassment. These are allegations, not findings, but they deserve independent scrutiny. A system that appears more willing to investigate junior officers than senior figures will not command confidence.
Violence against women and girls cannot be separated from policing. Women must be able to report abuse, harassment and violence with confidence that they will be taken seriously. That confidence is impossible to sustain if the institution responsible for responding to such crimes cannot demonstrate that it deals decisively with its own officers convicted of them. The conduct of serving officers also shapes whether women feel safe approaching the police.
The proposed reforms should be judged against a straightforward test: do they make the system genuinely independent, transparent and accountable at every rank? Rejecting changes that could speed up hearings and improve support for victims may leave existing problems unresolved. But creating a two-tier system, with independent oversight for senior officers and police-led hearings for junior ones, would not meet that test.
Farrell cannot place responsibility solely on regulations when the department responsible for professional standards sits within her own force. Nor can the Scottish Government treat this as an internal management issue. Eight convictions involving violence against women and girls, and the continued employment of those officers, demand answers. If Police Scotland expects women to trust it to protect them, it must first show that it is prepared to confront violence and misconduct within its own ranks.

