Is the Edinburgh Futures Institute “an important asset for the University, city and beyond,” or a “monumental capital over-investment”? These different perspectives demonstrate the tension at the heart of the debate about innovation and the future in Scotland.
The Edinburgh Futures Institute is an Edinburgh University facility which is part of the “Data-Driven Innovation initiative” and aims to “connect academia, industry and public-sector partners, mobilising data to achieve inclusive regional economic growth and positive social impact”.
That is the management view of EFI (and whatever else it is innovating, it is not innovating management jargon). The trade union sees it differently. It sees a facility which cost over £180 million, only earned a little over £600,000 in the last three years, has undershot its targets significantly and only has 50 members.
It sees an EFI which is currently delivering 12 undergraduate and postgraduate courses, but four of those courses are being cut because the university claims to be in significant financial distress. In other words, it sees another photo-friendly PR opportunity for the university, another management folly that is being paid for with staff job losses.
The concept behind the EFI is sound enough; there is good evidence that multidisciplinary working, which loosely links disparate projects working in different fields, can spark new cross-disciplinary thinking and collaborations. It is also right that successfully creating 'clusters' of high-innovation businesses can build more robust sectors and secure supply chain industries.
And it is also true that there is a well-studied 'innovation curve' where breakthroughs do not move in linear directions, get 'stuck' at certain phases and benefit from a degree of 'incubation' and support when progress is slower. Good facilities can make a difference to innovation.
Yet there is a flip side to this – you cannot just will innovators into being with a new building. Scotland is littered with the failures of supply-side growth and innovation initiatives. These include incubator units, 'accelerators', business parks, technology institutes, tech scalers and more.
And it is not just at the top end; Scotland has funded a range of these supply-side initiatives in high-level tech since devolution, but its local authorities have also pursued similar approaches, for example by dealing with the loss of a local employer by building four 'business units' for rent in the area.
The problem with all these supply-side measures is that they need to meet demand, and this is where Scotland keeps falling short. In this, the EFI is a case study; what the Institute needs to be a success is a wide range of innovative people and businesses which have learned core knowledge they can then commercialise in an ecosystem of similar research units and businesses.
But it is not just demand from producers that is needed; there has to be domestic market demand for what they produce. If Scotland is to gain the benefit, someone has to want to invest in and support the development of the idea in Scotland. In other words, there has to be a mature or at least maturing industry sector to help push innovation into markets.
Which is to say that the only thing missing from the Edinburgh Futures Institute is the people and the wider networks and ecosystems it needs, resources which are being choked off by cuts to teaching and research in universities.
Spending £180 million on the bit that photographs well and doing it by withdrawing the funding from the thing that could make it work at all but doesn't offer much of a photograph is a comparatively neat summary of Scotland's approach to economic development.

