Every few months, Common Weal has to put out another briefing to correct the misinformation which is spread by the nuclear industry in its aggressive lobbying of Scotland. Today it is claiming it can save us all money on grid infrastructure if we just build new nuclear. It is important to understand what is happening here.

Underlying all of this is that the nuclear industry has a weak case that does not stand up on its own. As we have shown many times, nuclear power is far and away the most expensive way to generate electricity and not a necessary part of Scotland's energy mix. The reality is that the cost of nuclear is three times as expensive as wind or solar, and that doesn't include taxpayer-funded decommissioning costs.

It is also an unhelpful source of electricity – nuclear power does not provide 'grid stability' because it is not fully dispatchable, meaning that while modern plants can ramp power up and down to meet demand, this can take hours as managing heat is complex. So nuclear cannot meet short-term surges in demand. You'd still need large-scale energy storage as well.

So given that Scotland has the renewable power it needs and that the gap in our system is storage, it is not clear what problem nuclear is meant to solve. Why do we spend so much time discussing a prohibitively expensive (and dangerous) technology which doesn't even provide us with proper grid stability? Private financial speculation and extensive lobbying spend are the answer.

What is its claim today? The Nuclear Industry Association claims that grid upgrade costs (which it grudgingly accepts are entirely necessary anyway) could be reduced somewhat if we built new nuclear power instead of designing the grid to take renewable energy. So how does that case stack up?

Renewable generation is disaggregated, so electricity must be 'collected' from a wider geographical area and routed to where demand is. The old National Grid was poorly designed for this since it was designed for a few large generation facilities rather than a disaggregated system.

The cost the nuclear industry wants to pin on this is £2 billion. It is knowingly leaning into anti-renewable arguments that are made in the right-wing media – that all these costs of renewables are being dumped on the consumer. There are two big holes in the nuclear case, however.

First of all, the grid would need upgrading no matter what. The ongoing electrification of our society means that the capacity of the old grid wasn't high enough to meet current and future needs. The electrification of transport alone will require a significant increase in capacity. Renewables or no renewables, we need to invest in the grid.

So the £2 billion is certainly not a 'renewables premium', though some costs will of course be higher than if we were just upgrading existing lines. But it is the second problem where it is hard to fathom why the lobbyists weren't challenged; how much money will it cost to 'save' some of this £2 billion in grid upgrades? The price of a new nuclear power plant.

And at what price does a new nuclear power plant start? About £5 billion for a small one. Hinkley Point C is currently scheduled to cost £35 billion, and that does not include decommissioning costs. What are those? There are direct public subsidies and giant tax breaks for the nuclear industry when it comes time to clean up the mess of old generation plants. That currently amounts to £4,600 per household in the UK.

So let's just restate the nuclear case honestly. To avoid each household in Scotland paying some proportion of £800 in bills over the next decade or two, it wants us to try and save some proportion of £2 billion in grid updates by spending at least £5 billion on a nuclear plant, which will result in the cost of electricity increasing by 300 per cent, so we can end up with a decommissioning bill of £4,600 being added to our bills instead.

Common Weal simply doesn't understand how this level of argument makes it into mainstream conversation unchallenged. It is not a serious case.


Next
Next

We’re trying to fix our economy by blaming young people again