We’re trying to fix our economy by blaming young people again

There is probably no point since the 1980s when there hasn't been concern over youth unemployment and nor has there been any point where there wasn't a government scheme which aimed to get young people into employment. We're about to get our latest iteration.

The Westminster Government is trailing its latest proposals on getting those not in employment, education or training (NEETs) into positive destinations. This is the result of a long-running review by Alan Milburn, which gives reason for concern. Milburn has long been willing to take some fairly right-wing solutions to youth unemployment and poverty problems.

Indeed he was commissioned by the Conservative Government to lead the Social Mobility Commission. He has often championed 'tough love' solutions very much in line with the ethos of New Labour. And yet these solutions always start with the same assumption – the problem of youth unemployment is a problem with young people.

The package of measures being floated is predictable; reduction in benefits, increase in compulsion, more training and apprenticeships... This time it has a contemporary feel because it is not 'lazy youths' that are the narrative target of the benefit cuts but 'those signed off on the sick'. This leans into the tabloid view of 'snowflakes' who are all off work with anxiety.

But this is yet again to frame society’s problems as a function of its victims rather than of our social structures. And it seems unrelated to the reality of the job market. For a start, there simply aren't as many jobs as job seekers. This graph shows that the absolute number of vacancies is significantly less than the number of job seekers.

And this graph shows how that breaks down by age – if every NEET were to get a job in the current labour market, there would not be a job available for a single person over 24. There just aren't enough jobs for all these young people to go into.

Nor does this seem to reflect other aspects of the current labour market. One of the most prevalent features of the current labour market is that employers are particularly cutting entry-level jobs. This means that not only is the labour market tight, it is also particularly difficult for young people starting out in their careers.

Of course, this is assuming there is any match between the jobs available and the careers young people are seeking to pursue. Common Weal has been talking to a lot of young people of late, and one comment was typical. A 30-year-old woman reported that not a single one of her friends was in a career related to their degree almost ten years after graduation.

Nor are the other factors affecting young people ones they themselves bear responsibility for. The housing market is now hostile to first-time buyers and housing costs can be crippling for young renters. And we have brought up this generation in a society in which the commercial exploitation of young people via social media, advertising, the 'celebrity lifestyle' industry and influencer culture is almost designed to undermine mental wellbeing.

We have also raised this generation on ultra-processed food, which we now know to have serious long-term impacts on health and mental health. In other words, we have created an environment almost designed to harm the wellbeing of young people while also generating an economy which is not providing them long-term opportunity.

This is not a problem of the will of young people – the stories of people receiving hundreds of rejections from employers, often via AI, are not because young people need a training course. More 'employment support' does not make housing more affordable. And government can certainly take disability support away from young people and coerce them into work or training, but that doesn't address their mental health.

When corporations face problems, it is generally presented as a failure by government, yet when young people face problems it is always framed as a problem with them. The simple reality is that you can neither train nor coerce people out of late-stage neoliberal capitalism and the AI revolution. This is just another way of scapegoating the young.

Which means it seems likely we will be less than a decade away from the next scheme which promises training but removes financial support for young people while doing nothing to reform the economy.


Next
Next

Is there no threshold for ‘too many health board scandals’?