It is worth noting that while a government policy completely collapsing before it is implemented or gradually falling apart after it is is hardly unheard of, it is not the norm. Or it didn't use to be. Today an analysis in the Herald suggests that the Scottish Government's education policy could be next.
What is most telling about the analysis is that much of what it identifies as the dynamic which could cause the policy to collapse is very familiar because it is the same dynamic which has caused other policies to fall apart. This has become a systemic problem in government.
One of the most frustrating things about this dynamic is that it begins with a good idea, proposal or solution. A National Care Services was a good idea and a realistic response to what amounts to a simmering crisis in care services. A National Energy Company could have been an effective response to overseas ownership of Scotland's energy resources.
But the next phase is typified by 'far too little' and 'far too much' at the same time. There is either too little ambition (both the National Care Service and National Energy Company were announced and then conceived as a shortcut which did as little as possible) or too little detail (the Curriculum for Excellence was good in conception but was initially far too vague in implementation).
And then there is far too much verbiage. Consultancy culture has changed how government is done in Scotland. Consultants get paid for reports not the implementation of policy and so they create reports that look like they were worth the often hundreds and thousands of pounds they cost.
For example, it took nearly four years and a total expenditure of just short of £500,000 for two private sector consultancies to conclude that the Government's plans for an energy company weren't viable. Yet Common Weal had made this point on the day the proposal was announced. You don't need to spend half a million pounds to know that the economics of energy retail meant the proposal wouldn't work.
(The Government tried to make it an energy retail company to reduce bills but the margins in retail energy are tiny and often heavily discounted for introductory periods so it was never the case that a public company could significantly reduce bills without subsidy. The opportunity was in public energy generation, which they refused to consider.)
Consultancy verbiage marks a lot of the bureaucracy around Curriculum for Excellence with guidance often being far too long while also being insufficiently specific. There has been a sense from the beginning that difficult decisions were ducked in favour of long, rambling, non-committal 'frameworks'.
And something as big as a national school curriculum needs to be responsive, to change. It should be driven by experts, and so when the review cycle took place teachers themselves made a lot of very sensible proposals for revisions. Except this is then more or less undone in another flurry of verbiage from the civil servants, returning the work largely to where it started before the consultation.
This is exactly what happened with the National Care Service. The consultation process was more about containing and controlling stakeholders and experts than listening to them, and the civil service simply kept pushing the same proposals with cosmetic changes.
It all amounts to a fundamentally poor policy development process and it fails in much the same way across different policy areas. Lack of clarity in conception, vague goals and aims, poorly considered proposals with lack of proper detail and failure to involve and listen to practitioners and key stakeholders is also imperilling local government reform and the wider public sector reform.
Effective policy starts with a clear goal, sets out some simple basic proposals, consults early with experts, practitioners and stakeholders, builds policy accordingly and focusses on an iterative process of detail development in which clear practical actions dominate and adjectives, descriptors, management jargon and vision statements are kept to a bare minimum.
It took less time to launch the National Health Service start to finish than it did for the Scottish Government to learn its energy company policy wasn't feasible, something that was knowable with five minutes of desk-based research before the policy was announced.
The legislation establishing the NHS has about 35,000 words; the first of one set of the 'Building a Curriculum' guidance notes on Curriculum for excellence has 12,000. There are nine of them. Why does legislation keep collapsing? Because it is ill-conceived and then its weaknesses are covered over by long, unwieldy guidance notes which make life harder for frontline workers.

