You can’t train young people for jobs that don’t exist

Alan Milburn’s review recognises that young people face a shrinking labour market, but employability programmes alone cannot solve a shortage of decent jobs. This week’s In Common suggests we need to look beyond getting young people into work and ask why the economy is failing to give them somewhere to go.

A young person can do everything asked of them and still arrive at a locked door. They study, collect qualifications, complete an apprenticeship, polish a CV and send applications into the quiet machinery of online recruitment. They are told to show initiative, gain experience and make themselves indispensable. Then the entry-level job requires experience, the graduate role has hundreds of applicants, and the work they trained for is not there.

This is the landscape against which Alan Milburn’s review of youth employment, From a Welfare State to a Working State, should be judged. Nearly one million young people are not in education, employment or training. It is tempting to describe this as a problem of motivation or readiness. The review is more honest: it recognises that opportunity has contracted, even as young people are asked to do more to prove they deserve it.

Milburn identifies a hollowing-out of the first rung of the career ladder. Youth employment has fallen while overall employment has grown. Successive governments have concentrated on making young people more employable, taking for granted that the labour market will provide somewhere for them to go. That assumption has become difficult to defend.

An Opportunity Guarantee would offer a route into a job, apprenticeship, education or training; a Support Guarantee would bring employment advice, health services and practical assistance together. The proposed Youth Opportunity Service could make support more coherent by working locally through existing organisations. Expanding apprenticeships and encouraging employers to create first-job opportunities are sensible ambitions.

But a guarantee is only as real as the opportunity behind it.

The review acknowledges employers’ retreat from entry-level recruitment. It proposes hiring incentives and asks employers and public services to create first-rung roles. Yet the response risks making young workers cheaper to employ without confronting why secure entry-level work has become scarce.

There is a difference between helping people compete for jobs and creating jobs for people to compete for. If employers continue to cut junior positions, demand two years’ experience for graduate roles, or leave applicants unanswered by automated recruitment systems, another employability programme cannot repair the damage. Training can prepare someone for work. It cannot conjure the work into existence.

“You can neither starve nor train a generation into a career that does not exist”

Nor does the problem end at 24. The review focuses on people aged 16 to 24, but the barriers it describes do not vanish on a twenty-fifth birthday. Graduates can spend years studying and emerge into a labour market where the jobs they trained for are unavailable, or closed to them because they lack experience they have never been given the chance to acquire. Apprentices and others who followed the dependable route into professional employment can find themselves moving between temporary contracts, low-paid work and applications that lead nowhere.

Milburn’s own research recognises the disappointment of graduates who did what was expected of them, gained qualifications and still could not secure suitable first jobs. They reach the end of the path they were told to follow and find that the bridge into employment is missing.

Qualifications have become increasingly necessary to access work, but they are not necessarily enough to secure it. Experience is demanded for entry-level posts; unpaid or poorly paid work is presented as a stepping stone; and employers can afford to be selective when applicants outnumber vacancies.

There is a further danger in measuring success by whether people enter any available job. Employment is not automatically an escape from insecurity. The low-pay, no-pay cycle describes how people can move repeatedly between unemployment and poorly paid, insecure work without gaining stability or progression. A first job matters. So does whether it pays enough to live on, offers security, develops skills and opens a route forward.

The review’s proposed shift towards a more conditional welfare system deserves scrutiny, too. Its guarantees come with new obligations to engage, and sanctions remain a backstop. Milburn argues that support and opportunities should be in place before benefit changes are introduced. That order matters. But no support service can manufacture vacancies, make housing affordable or compel an employer to offer decent work. Without those changes, coercion risks recasting economic failure as an individual duty.

The review begins a conversation. It recognises that the labour market has failed young people, that employers must take greater responsibility and that opportunity should not depend on family connections or luck. But those acknowledgements must shape the reforms themselves.

That means investment in good jobs, stronger employment rights, properly funded further and higher education, meaningful apprenticeships and an economy that creates opportunities beyond short-term profitability. Employers must take responsibility for training and progression, rather than expecting every applicant to arrive fully formed. Success should be measured not by how many young people are moved off benefits or into any job, but by whether they can build a secure and fulfilling life.

Young people do not need another lecture about their readiness for the world of work. They need an economy ready to give them a chance. You can neither starve nor train a generation into a career that does not exist.

Previous
Previous

Chimps see it, we see it, politicians don't

Next
Next

Angry about scams? Be angry about scam-onomics